Question 1

Which legal structure should I choose: LLC, JSC, or Sole Proprietorship (Individual Entrepreneur)?

Accepted Answer

- Sole Proprietorship: Best suited for early-stage validation, solo consultants, or freelancers. It offers minimal compliance reporting and effortless capital repatriation. Primary Risk: Unlimited personal liability extending to all personal assets.
    
- LLC (Limited Liability Company): The optimal corporate structure for multi-partner businesses and venture capital injection. Member liability is strictly limited to the nominal value of their respective equity contributions in the share capital.
    
- JSC (Joint Stock Company): Mandatory for large-scale enterprises, banking, insurance sectors, or businesses targeting institutional capital via public listings (IPOs). Characterized by highly rigid governance models and stringent disclosure mandates.

Question 2

Why do I need a Shareholders' Agreement (SHA) if the company already has Articles of Association?

Accepted Answer

The Articles of Association are a matter of public record and provide only the baseline statutory rules. A Shareholders' Agreement (SHA) is strictly confidential and governs private contractual relationships between partners, specifying:

- Capital call commitments: Who is obligated to invest, under what milestones, and into which projects.
    
- Allocation of executive seats, board representation, and operational spheres of control.
    
- Deadlock resolution mechanisms in 50/50 split voting scenarios (e.g., Texas Shoot-out or Russian Roulette clauses).
    
- Specific voting pools or covenants compelling partners to vote in a predetermined manner on key matters.

Question 3

What remedies are available if a business partner blocks corporate operations or passes ultra vires resolutions?

Accepted Answer

- Review of Articles and SHA: Audit the corporate governance documents for deadlock-breaking provisions or buy-sell triggers based on contractually agreed valuation formulas.
    
- Corporate Audit & Revocation: Formally initiate an extraordinary financial and operational audit. Unlawful resolutions passed by management or the general assembly must be challenged in court via nullity actions.
    
- Derivative Actions: If a partner or director’s breach of fiduciary duties caused measurable financial harm to the corporation, members holding the statutory threshold may file a derivative lawsuit on behalf of the LLC to recover damages from the wrongdoer.

Question 4

How can an uncooperative or bad-faith member be lawfully expelled from an LLC?

Accepted Answer

Under the Ukrainian LLC Law, a member can be expelled via general meeting resolution on two statutory grounds only:

1. Failure to fund capital contribution commitments within the prescribed statutory timeline (including any cure period extended by the company).
    
2. Death of an individual member or liquidation of a corporate entity where heirs or legal successors fail to submit an application to join the company within 1 year.

Crucial Note: Squeezing out or expelling a partner simply due to "disruptive behavior" or general deadlock via a majority vote is strictly barred by law. Redress in such cases must be pursued through claims for damages or court-ordered equity buyouts.

Question 5

How can a member defend themselves against an attempted hostile expulsion or squeeze-out?

Accepted Answer

- Evidentiary Audit: Ensure your initial equity contribution is fully paid up and backed by ironclad primary financial evidence (bank transfer records, deposit slips, property transfer deeds).
    
- Injunctive Relief & Voidance Actions: If management attempts dilution through unauthorized capital increases executed behind your back or holds meetings violating quorum/notice requirements, immediately file an action in commercial court to void the resolutions. Simultaneously request urgent interim measures (injunctions blocking the state registrar from recording changes).

Question 6

Can a managing director sell corporate assets without member approval?

Accepted Answer

Only if the asset valuation falls within statutory or charter-defined limits. Statutorily, if the market value of a transaction exceeds 50% of the company's net assets calculated at the end of the preceding quarter, the director must secure prior approval via a general meeting resolution. If the Articles of Association impose stricter thresholds (e.g., board approval for any contract exceeding $5,000), the director cannot act autonomously. Contracts executed in violation of these restriction limits are voidable and can be set aside by a court.

Question 7

What is the procedure for challenging a resolution passed by the General Meeting?

Accepted Answer

- Grounds: Defective notice periods (failure to notify 30 days in advance), lack of statutory or contractual quorum, voting on items absent from the formal agenda, or direct violations of statutory law or the Articles of Association.
    
- Forum: A statement of claim must be filed with the commercial court at the registered seat of the LLC.
    
- Statute of Limitations: While the statutory limit for certain corporate resolutions stands at 1,000 days (or the general 3-year limitation period, with specific resolutions shortened to 1 year), swift filing is highly recommended to prevent asset dissipation.

Question 8

What is the proper procedure for withdrawing from an LLC and recovering equity value?

Accepted Answer

The mechanism depends entirely on your equity stake:

- Stakes below 50%: You maintain an absolute right to withdraw at any time without requiring consent from other members. The process is executed via a notary who records the amendment directly in the State Register.
    
- Stakes of 50% or greater: Voluntary withdrawal is restricted and requires the unanimous consent of all other members.
    
- Settlement: The corporation is statutorily obligated to remit the fair market value of your share (pro-rata to the net asset value of the LLC) within 1 year from the effective date of withdrawal, unless an alternative timeline is explicitly structured in the Articles.

Question 9

How do I sell my LLC shares, and what are the key contractual safeguards?

Accepted Answer

- Right of First Refusal (ROFR): Audit the Articles. Existing members have a statutory right of first refusal to purchase your shares. You must formally notify them in writing of your intent to sell, including the price and terms. If they fail to exercise this right within 30 days, you are free to sell to a third party.
    
- Contractual Form: The Share Purchase Agreement (SPA) must be executed in writing and requires mandatory notarization alongside the share transfer deed.
    
- Payment Security: Utilize secure transaction mechanics, such as bank escrow accounts or Letters of Credit (LC), ensuring clear funds are locked before transferring title at the notary or via the Diia digital governance application.

Question 10

What is Due Diligence, and why is it mandatory prior to an acquisition?

Accepted Answer

Due Diligence is a rigorous, pre-contractual investigatory audit of the target business. It spans four critical pillars: Legal (litigation risks, clean title to intellectual property, asset ownership, regulatory licenses), Financial, Tax, and Operational/Technical risks.

Strategic Value: Foregoing due diligence leaves the buyer exposed to acquiring a corporate shell burdened with undisclosed liabilities, frozen bank accounts, fraudulent supplier agreements, or defective intellectual property titles that undermine the company's core value.

Question 11

What are the primary legal risks when buying an existing business in Ukraine?

Accepted Answer

- Hidden Tax Liabilities: Historical tax deficits, aggressive transfer pricing, or risky transactions with shell companies that will inevitably trigger back-taxes and penalties during subsequent state tax audits.
    
- Defective Corporate Title: Squeeze-out flaws or failure to secure spousal asset waivers from the seller, which can prompt third-party claims to void the transaction.
    
- Loss of Intangible Assets: Material commercial leases or critical operational licenses containing Change of Control clauses that trigger automatic termination upon equity transfer.

Question 12

What is an SPA, and what representations and warranties should a buyer demand?

Accepted Answer

A Share Purchase Agreement (SPA) is the definitive contract governing the acquisition. The core defensive section centers on Representations and Warranties (R&Ws). The seller must represent under contract that:

- The target company has no undisclosed debts, off-balance-sheet liabilities, or hidden corporate guarantees.
    
- There is no pending, threatened, or imminent civil, criminal, or regulatory litigation.
    
- All tax filings are accurate, fully paid, and compliant with applicable codes.
    
- The company holds unencumbered, clear legal title to all physical assets and proprietary software source code.

If any R&Ws prove false post-closing, the buyer triggers contractual Indemnity provisions to claw back damages.

Question 13

When is prior AMCU merger clearance mandatory for an acquisition?

Accepted Answer

Approval from the Antimonopoly Committee of Ukraine (AMCU) is required if the financial metrics of the transactional parties (aggregating all related corporate entities/groups) for the previous fiscal year breach either of these thresholds:

1. The combined global asset value or turnover exceeds EUR 30 million, and the aggregate Ukrainian asset value or turnover of at least two distinct participants exceeds EUR 4 million each.
    
2. The Ukrainian asset value or turnover of the target company exceeds EUR 4 million, and the global aggregate turnover of at least one other participant breaches EUR 100 million.

Question 14

How should an M&A transaction be structured to minimize tax exposure?

Accepted Answer

- Asset Deal vs. Share Deal: A Share Deal inherits the target's entire historical tax liability. If the legacy risks are prohibitive, the transaction is structured as an Asset Deal—the clean acquisition of isolated assets (equipment, trademarks, real estate) by a newly incorporated corporate vehicle.
    
- Holding Interposition: Conducting transactions via international holding hubs (e.g., jurisdictions offering participation exemptions on capital gains, like Cyprus or the Netherlands) while ensuring strict alignment with Controlled Foreign Corporation (CFC) rules and MLI treaty provisions.

Question 15

How can a minority shareholder protect themselves against oppressive majority actions?

Accepted Answer

Minority equity holders can insulate themselves via:

- The Articles of Association: Introducing supermajority or unanimity (100% vote) thresholds for core decisions (amending the articles, material asset disposals, liquidation).
    
- Shareholders' Agreements: Negotiating Tag-Along rights (compelling the majority owner to ensure that any third-party buyer extends the same purchase terms to the minority holder).
    
- Statutory Audits: Ukrainian corporate law grants any member holding a 10%+ equity stake the unconditional right to mandate an independent financial audit of the company at their own expense.

Question 16

What should a client expect during the initial consultation, and what documentation is required?

Accepted Answer

Preparation and Document Checklist:

- Passport and Tax ID (for individual members) or an extract from the State Register along with current corporate bylaws (for entities).
    
- The current operative version of the Articles of Association and any executed Shareholders' Agreements.
    
- General meeting minutes, board appointments, executive resolutions, and property deeds (if addressing a corporate dispute).
    
- Draft contracts, historical audit findings, or partner correspondence (if structuring an M&A transaction).

Pro Tip: Providing a brief chronological summary of the dispute or deal objectives via email 24 hours prior to the session allows the attorney to audit public registers beforehand, maximizing billable efficiency from minute one.

Question 17

What is the premier jurisdiction for incorporation: Ukraine, Estonia, Poland, or Lithuania?

Accepted Answer

The optimal selection depends entirely on operational metrics:

- Ukraine: Unrivaled for local manufacturing, localized retail, or tech engineering teams due to the specialized Diia City tax regime (5% personal income tax / 9% exit tax options).
    
- Estonia: The global gold standard for digital nomads, SaaS startups, and borderless digital teams. Features a 0% corporate income tax on retained or reinvested profits until distribution.
    
- Poland: The premier launchpad for entry into the physical EU market, supply chains, e-commerce fulfillment, and seamless access to corporate banking rails.
    
- Lithuania: The premier EU jurisdiction for fintech innovations, digital asset firms, and securing expedited EMI/PI financial licenses under a collaborative regulator.

Question 18

What is Estonian e-Residency, and how does it facilitate corporate setup?

Accepted Answer

e-Residency is a government-issued digital identity that grants global entrepreneurs the ability to incorporate and manage an EU-based entity 100% remotely.

- The Process: You apply online and collect your digital ID card at an Estonian consulate. The card enables you to incorporate an Estonian OÜ online in minutes, sign contracts using EU-compliant qualified electronic signatures (QES), file taxes remotely, and open accounts with prominent European neo-banks and PSPs (Wise, Revolut, Stripe).

Legal Notice: e-Residency provides business infrastructure only; it does not grant physical residency, citizenship, or automatic Estonian personal tax residency.

Question 19

How does a Polish sp. z o.o. differ from a Ukrainian LLC?

Accepted Answer

The Polish sp. z o.o. (Spółka z ograniczoną responsabilité) is the direct equivalent of an LLC, with distinct operational nuances:

- Minimum share capital is set at a low threshold of PLN 5,000 (Ukraine has no statutory minimum).
    
- Foreign directors typically require a Polish PESEL identification number and an ePUAP digital profile for governance filings.
    
- The Corporate Income Tax (CIT) for small businesses (turnover under EUR 2 million) is a competitive 9% (compared to the standard 19% rate; Ukraine's standard rate is 18%).
    
- Banking compliance features rigorous KYC protocols for ultimate beneficial owners (UBOs) residing outside the European Economic Area.

Question 20

What are the strategic reasons for incorporating in Lithuania?

Accepted Answer

Lithuania is widely utilized by FinTech, software development, and international logistics operations.

- Key Incentives: Rapid regulatory scaling for payment infrastructure, a reduced 5% corporate tax rate for small businesses (under 10 employees and under EUR 300,000 annual turnover), and an attractive 5% IP Box tax rate on income generated from proprietary patented assets or copyrighted software.

Question 21

How should commercial relationships with Chinese partners be structured to mitigate risks?

Accepted Answer

- First-to-File Trademark Protections: China strictly enforces a first-to-file trademark system. Register your intellectual property and brand assets in mainland China before commencing negotiations; otherwise, factory counterparties routinely register them, blocking your export chains.
    
- NNN Agreements under Chinese Law: Standard western NDAs are largely unenforceable in mainland China. You require a tailored NNN Agreement (Non-disclosure, Non-circumvention, Non-competition). It must be executed in the Chinese language, specify governing law in mainland China, place dispute resolution before Chinese courts or CIETAC arbitration, and feature enforceable liquidated damages provisions targeting the factory's local assets.

Question 22

What are the operational differences between Dubai Mainland and Free Zones like the DIFC?

Accepted Answer

- Mainland Entities: Registered to conduct commerce directly within the domestic UAE market. Subject to standard UAE federal laws and the federal corporate tax framework (9% CIT on taxable profits exceeding AED 375,000).
    
- Free Zones: Designed for global trade and digital services. They offer 0% corporate and personal tax guarantees, customs duty exemptions, and 100% foreign corporate ownership.
    
- DIFC (Dubai International Financial Centre): A premium financial free zone operating under an independent, sovereign legal framework rooted entirely in English Common Law. It maintains its own English-language judicature (DIFC Courts) and serves as the premier regional hub for asset management, venture funds, and institutional corporate structuring.

Question 23

How do I attract US venture capital, and what are SAFE instruments and Delaware C-Corporations?

Accepted Answer

US institutional funds and top-tier accelerators are structurally restricted from investing directly into non-US legal entities. To bridge this, international startups execute a Flip-Up transaction—interposing a US holding company above their domestic operating LLC.

- Delaware C-Corp: A corporation registered in Delaware. It remains the absolute mandate for venture capital investors globally due to highly flexible corporate statutes and the specialized Court of Chancery, which provides unrivaled legal predictability.
    
- SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity): An investment instrument where an investor injects early-stage capital into a startup today in exchange for a contractual right to receive equity shares during a future priced financing round (e.g., Series A). SAFEs utilize key mechanisms like a Valuation Cap or a Discount Rate, bypassing prolonged valuation negotiations during seed stages.

Question 24

What is the CISG, and how is governing law determined in international trade contracts?

Accepted Answer

The CISG (United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods) is a binding international treaty that automatically governs cross-border B2B sales contracts if the trading parties reside in nations that have ratified the convention (such as Ukraine, the US, China, and most EU member states). It standardizes rules regarding delivery, risk transfer, and breach remedies.

- Governing Law Determination: Contractual parties retain absolute autonomy to select their applicable governing law (e.g., English Law, Swiss Law). If a choice-of-law clause is omitted from the contract, the applicable framework is determined via private international law conflicts rules (typically defaulting to the law of the seller's seat) or interpreted through the baseline provisions of the CISG.

Service	Price
Initial Oral Consultation	Free
Express Situation Review / Document Assessment	from $50
Written Legal Opinion / Formal Legal Memorandum	from $150
Formal Attorney’s Statutory Information Request	from $100
Full-Service LLC Incorporation (Articles, State Register, Corporate Seal)	from $250
Drafting or Comprehensive Review of Articles of Association	from $200
Drafting tailored Shareholders' Agreement (SHA)	from $500
Registration of Corporate Changes (Changes to Directors, Members, or Articles)	from $150
Comprehensive Legal Due Diligence of a Target Company	from $1,000
Drafting Transactional Documents (NDA / LOI / Term Sheet)	from $200
Drafting Share Purchase Agreement (SPA)	from $450
End-to-End Turnkey M&A Transaction Legal Support	from $2,500
Corporate Reorganization or Voluntary Liquidation	from $600
Drafting Statement of Claim in a Corporate Dispute	from $350
Legal Representation in the Commercial Court of First Instance	from $800
Drafting Appellate Court Briefs in Corporate Litigation	from $500
Legal Representation before the Court of Appeals	from $1,000
Drafting Cassation Appeal to the Supreme Court	from $800
Legal Representation before the Supreme Court of Ukraine	from $1,500
Monthly Corporate Retainer / General Counsel Services	Subject to Retainer Agreement
Company Registration in Estonia (OÜ / e-Residency)	from $350
Company Registration in Poland (sp. z o.o.)	from $500
Company Registration in Lithuania (UAB)	from $600
Advisory on International Jurisdictions & Holding Structure Setup	from $250
Drafting International Commercial Contracts / Cross-Border Agreements	from $350
Legal Support for Cross-Border Transactions (Partners in PRC / US / EU / UAE)	from $600

Corporate Law

How we handle your case

Free consultation and assessment

Contract signing and start of work

Preparation and strategy development

Representation and outcome

Practice areas (categories)

Pricing

FAQ

Let's discuss your case